Proposal to Study Effects of Ban on Third Party Puppy and Kitten Sales under Lucy's Law in England

Mr Louis Ng Kok Kwang asked the Minister for National Development (a) whether the Ministry will consider studying the effects of the ban on third-party puppy and kitten sales under Lucy's Law in England; (b) if so, whether the Ministry will consider implementing a similar law in Singapore which is adapted to our local context; and (c) if not, why not.

Lucy's Law was recently passed in England in April 2020. Hence, it is too early for us to assess its effectiveness on improving animal welfare, and its impact on the pet industry. NParks will consider regulatory developments in other jurisdictions, including Lucy's Law, when it reviews its regulations to safeguard animal welfare.

In Singapore, we are similarly concerned about the welfare of pets that are bred and sold. NParks has a licensing framework in place to safeguard the health and welfare of animals at pet breeders and pet shops. In October 2021, NParks announced tightened licensing conditions for pet breeders to raise industry standards and improve the health and welfare of animals. To ensure traceability and compliance with licensing conditions, NParks conducts regular inspections on licensed pet breeders and pet shops. NParks also investigates reports of unlicensed pet breeding and sales, and also takes enforcement action against the offenders.

With this regulatory framework in place, NParks does not see the need to introduce a ban on third-party puppy and kitten sales at this juncture. NParks will continue to review regulations under the Animals and Birds Act with relevant stakeholders to ensure that they remain effective in safeguarding animal health and welfare. Should the public come across animal welfare breaches, they should report them to NParks for investigation.